Blog

How do you people think spam filters work? [Mailbag]

January 25th, 2012 by David A.M. Wilensky

Deerson and Ron Paul after a talk in March | Courtesy of David Deerson

You may recall our story from last week about David Deerson, the Bible-quoting Jewish college student who supports Ron Paul. (If you haven’t read it yet, you should.)

Someone called Adrian Wainer read it and attempted to deposit the following comment. He begins by quoting Deerson from the article:

“‘I think it [a Jewish State] has an absolute right to exist. The question is: Is it wise or prudent to exist in that specific area of the world, given the sort of geopolitical conditions of today?’ Deerson said in a telephone interview.”

Maybe Israel should exist on the f8cking Moon according according to Deerson, oh I forgot the Islamists claim the entire Solar System and Galaxy for Islam, what to do, “kill all the Jews “, which might well be what that piece of sh-one-t Ron Paul wants.

I’m not gonna get into all of the, er, issues Wainer raises here, but his comment did give me this question to ponder: How do you people think spam filters work?

Lower tuition… yay! Israel and Iran… meh… [State of the Students]

January 25th, 2012 by Zach C. Cohen

Everybody and their mother is trying to predict what’s going to happen in the 2012 race to the White House. At New Voices, we’re wondering what college students will vote for. Well, tonight may have given us a hint.

Most college students use their Tuesday night to catch up on homework or party before class-free Wednesday.

At American University in Washington, D.C., its student newspaper (which, by the way, I also work for) The Eagle proclaims, “It’s time for the most anticipated televised event of the year at AU. Nope, not the Super Bowl. It’s the State of the Union!”

AU College Democrats gathered the campus political junkies in The Tavern, AU’s bar-turned-hamburger-and-burrito-joint. As early as half and hour before showtime, students milled about, bought themselves a turkey cheese steak and settled in for President Barack Obama’s sixth statement to a joint session of Congress.

AU’s known to be a pretty liberal campus, so it was not surprising that Obama got a raucous round of applause when he began to give his State of the Union.

But what’s even more interesting is what students didn’t seem to care about. Obama’s celebration of global teamwork to stop Iranian nuclear weaponry, and the subsequent growth of Iranian sanctions, received barely any response from the gathered students. Obama’s mention of support for Israel received only a polite golf clap.

But students were apathetic about more than just the United States’s relationship with Israel. Approval for a clean energy economy and reaction to Obama’s gratitude to American soldiers was tepid at best.

But there were certainly highlights for students watching the president’s address happening only six miles away. Students naturally chuckled (by chuckled, I mean literally laughed out loud) at House Majority Leader Eric Cantor’s (Republican of Virginia and surprise Jew) visible conniption at Obama’s call for a payroll taxes and First Lady Michelle Obama’s embarrassed reaction to Barack’s joke gone sour.

But when it came to education costs, students came just short of jumping out of their seats in exultation. When Obama said the cost of college was too high, one student, with sarcasm dripping, loudly asked, “Really?”

Everybody else in the room laughed in agreement.

Obama continued to please AU Eagles when he called for more work-study financial aid, demanded lower student loan interest rates and, most importantly, scolded universities for raising tuition too much.

“Let me put colleges and universities on notice: If you can’t stop tuition from going up, the funding you get from taxpayers will go down,” Obama said.

Students responded in kind with surprised enthusiasm for the Commander in Chief’s hardline against rising tuition, an issue students at AU are all too familiar with.

But students’ passion shone through where they cared. Applause and cheers abounded for:

  • The end of Don’t Ask Don’t Tell,
  • Decreasing our debt and “nation building at home,”
  • Continuing American exceptionalism,
  • The creation of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau,
  • Prevention of another BP oil spill,
  • More bipartisanship in Congress,
  • Equal pay for women,
  • The DREAM ACT and immigration reform
  • And most of all, the death of Osama Bin Laden.

Piss on the Queen of England [Global Jewish Voice]

January 23rd, 2012 by Gabriel T. Erbs

Israeli native Liran Shamriz grew up with rabid, Israel-obsessed articles an international media mainstay. Here, he turns the tables.

French people are whores and Americans are all fat and stupid.

If that makes you angry, then I’ve succeeded. If not, just tell me who you are and I will find the words to make you feel the way I feel when I read a foreign news article about Israel.

[...]

News reporters are supposed to search for the truth. But it doesn’t happen anymore. All I can feel is their search for fame through cheap headlines.

Two examples, in two top newspapers in the world, of outrageous headlines: “Israel is a Pirate State,” from the French newspaper Liberation referring to the Gaza Flotilla

[...]

Sometimes, the articles don’t do justice to the headlines. In the English Guardian newspaper, we see “Mutilated children of a Crippled Palestine.” The article doesn’t read as inflammatory, (as inflammatory). The bashing isn’t just the result of a few outspoken journalists – this is editorial discretion.

[...]

Keep reading at the Global Jewish Voice.

Citing ‘Star Trek’ and Tom Clancy, Jewish journalist suggests Israel might assassinate Obama; Secret Service looking into it [Parsing]

January 23rd, 2012 by David A.M. Wilensky

Hey, Andrew, how'd that "Your Jewish Community" event go?

As JTA reported on Friday, Atlanta Jewish Times Owner/Publisher Andrew Adler had what I can only assume was a 1,000-word psychotic episode in print a couple of weeks ago. This unfortunate loss of his mental faculties caused him to propose that, among other options Israel must obviously be mulling over for the sake of its own security, they were probably thinking about, you know, maybe having President Obama whacked by secret agents.

His airtight thinking on this matter:

Yes, you read “three” correctly. Order a hit on a president in order to preserve Israel’s existence. Think about it. If I have thought of this Tom Clancy-type scenario, don’t you think that this almost unfathomable idea has been discussed in Israel’s most inner circles?

[...]

You have go to believe, like I do, that all options are on the table.

I’ve taken Adler’s advice on this and thought about it, but I’ve come to a different conclusion: Just because conspiracy-minded wing-nuts have a particularly off-the-rails idea doesn’t mean that world leaders have had the same idea.

By the time of the JTA article, Adler had already promised to issue an apology in the next issue of the Atlanta Jewish Times. (“I very much regret it. I wish I hadn’t made reference to it at all,” he said.) However, that did not stop American Jewish Committee head honcho David Harris from posting a typically aneurysm-ridden piece on his Jerusalem Post blog, In The Trenches.

On Saturday, CNN had a special take on the story, evident in this headline: “Jewish paper’s column catches Secret Service eye.” Their story said:

U.S. Secret Service spokesman George Ogilvie told CNN Saturday, “We are aware of it. We are taking the appropriate investigative steps.”

Today, JTA twitched out one of its alarmingly subject-lined emails (“BREAKING NEWS:…” and so forth) to report that Adler was not only going to apologize, as their initial report said, but that he has resigned:

The owner and publisher of the Atlanta Jewish Times has resigned and is seeking a buyer in the wake of a column he wrote speculating that Israel would consider assassinating President Obama.

Andrew Adler, in an email obtained by JTA, announced Monday that he is “relinquishing all day-to-day activities effective immediately”….

Now we’re just waiting for more BREAKING NEWS, when JTA learns that Adler has also had himself committed.

A few final thoughts on this exciting news item:

  • We hear lots of talk about Jewish voters abandoning Obama in 2012. At least know we what’s really over the line for them; this column had the Jewish community of Atlanta (not to mention Harris and the ADL) calling for Adler’s head.
  • On the same page as the offending column (see above image), the Atlanta Jewish Times ran an ad for an event called “Your Jewish Community,” trumpeting the event’s host, one Andrew B. Adler. The event was scheduled for two days after the column was published. I wonder how that event turned out.
  • Aside from implying that he might be his generation’s great undiscovered political thriller author with that Clancy reference, Adler also managed to squeeze a “Star Trek” reference into the column, saying that he had come up with Bibi Netanyahu’s three “Kobayashi Maru” scenarios. He explained that this is a reference to “Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan,” in which the term is used to refer to a no-win scenario. He is apparently too much of an old fuddy-duddy to know that the Kobayashi Maru is referenced just as heavily in JJ Abrams’ 2009 “Star Trek” film. And the American Jewish press wonders why it doesn’t have any young readers….

 

Jewish student for Ron Paul; Perry is out; who’s next? [Today in New Voices]

January 19th, 2012 by David A.M. Wilensky

David Deerson, a junior at University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill meets Ron Paul | Zach C. Cohen

It took New Voices Associate Editor Zach C. Cohen (also recently dubbed New Voices politics correspondent as well) some time to find a Jewish student who supports Ron Paul, but our ace reporter found one. Check out his story:

David Deerson went to Jewish day school, attended and worked at a Jewish summer camp and he has been to Israel multiple times. He also thinks the Jewish State might as well be in Wyoming. And he’s voting for Ron Paul in 2012.

Read the full story here.

Next, we might have gone after a Jewish student supporter of Michele Bachmann, but that ship has long since sailed. Failing that, Rick Perry would have been next on our list, but news of the end of his campaign and his endorsement of Newt Gingrich hit today.

So next up, we’re on the lookout for a Jewish student with a thing for Mitt Romney (which shouldn’t be too hard to find), a Gingrich supporter (which may be a little harder to find) or a Jewish student who has anything other than total contempt for Rick Santorum. If you know someone who fits any of those descriptions, help us out! Which one would you rather see next? Let us know in the comments or email Zach at zach@newvoices.org.

Why we should sanction Iran, even though it won’t work [Parsing]

January 19th, 2012 by David A.M. Wilensky

Gary Hufbauer says sanctions don't work. Except for when they do | iie.com

I listen to NPR’s Planet Money podcast to understand basic news about the economy because it puts things simply. And because I don’t know my head from my ass when it comes to economics.

But sometimes they take hard economics and deploy it as a way of looking at something in the news in a different light, deploying some economist or the other in an offbeat way. Their “Do Sanctions Work?” podcast from earlier this week is one of those. In it, sanctions expert Gary Hufbauer tells the Planet Money’s Adam Davidson that sanctions only work about 30 percent of the time, usually only on very small economies — and that we should continue using them on Iran anyway.

Generally, we (the Jewish press, the press, the Jews, people in general — take your pick) take it for granted that the way stop Iran from developing a nuclear weapon without actually going to war is to use economic sanctions. But noting Israeli skepticism on that front, The Forward wrote today:

As the United States moves toward the final stage of imposing sanctions against Iran’s central bank and oil industry, American officials are trying to erase Israeli suspicion about the effectiveness of economic pressure and to ensure that Jerusalem and Washington are fully coordinated in dealing with Iran’s nuclear threat.

Meanwhile, Tablet‘s Marc Tracy, always such a ray of sunshine on these issues, has nothing but optimism in a blog post today titled, “On Iran, Most Roads Lead to Bad Places: A look at what could happen in the coming months.”

Hufbauer basically agrees, at least when it comes to the efficacy of sanctions. After saying that economic sanctions only work about 30 percent of the time, he says that they’re actually quite effective. Upon hearing that, Davidson basically does a double-take, saying that every example of economic sanctions he can think of was a total failure. Hufbauer says, yeah, those are the ones you’ve heard of, and then rattles of a couple of examples of how sanctions can be tremendously effective on small, poor economies. Then he says that as far as tools for applying international pressure without starting a war go, a proven success rate of 30 percent is pretty damn good.

But in the end, Hufbauer doesn’t think economic sanctions will work on Iran; their economy is just too big. Yet, he thinks we should keep using them anyway. In fact, he says, we should use sanctions to squeeze Iran as hard as we possible can. Why? Because then it will be easier to make the case that we tried every possible thing if we have to convince the world it’s time to go to war with Iran.

But what do I know? Listen to the podcast for the full story.

New Voices blogger Gabe Schivone’s new HuffPo column [All grown up]

January 18th, 2012 by Harpo Jaeger

Our own Gabe Schivone, who wrote the interview series Other Voices last semester, has moved on to his very own Huffington Post column.  His first piece is up:

Any free society–from Margaret Thatcher’s Apartheid-era Britain to Obama’s currently anti-immigrant America–cannot expect to adequately deal with the sort of violence that prompted the Tucson shootings while refusing to address, much less acknowledge, the greater violence connected to government policy plaguing our neighbors in the AZ-Sonora deserts and cities, and communities nationwide, year after year.

We’ll miss Gabe’s ongoing enthusiasm for all aspects of Palestinian solidarity work, and wish him the best in his new endeavor!

Civil rights investigation at Columbia dropped [Israel on campus]

January 17th, 2012 by Harpo Jaeger
NYC - Columbia University - Low Memorial Library

Photo by flickr user wallyg (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

In September, an Orthodox student at Barnard claimed that a faculty advisor, Professor Rachel McDermott, steered her away from a class taught by an allegedly anti-Israel professor.  As a result, the Institute for Jewish & Community Research filed a complaint with the New York Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights.  The Forward reported last week that the OCR has now dropped the investigation:

“Because of the conflicting version of events and no other evidence to support the complainant’s allegation, the [Office of Civil Rights] determined that there was insufficient evidence to substantiated the complainant’s allegation,” the decision reads.

Interestingly, the case (even after its dismissal) may set the precedent that Jewish students are deserving of legal protection as a discrete ethnic group, according to Kenneth Marcus, a former OCR director who filed the complaint:

“This case establishes for the first time that Jewish college students have a legal right against racial steering. Never before had [the Office of Civil Rights] acknowledged that they will assert jurisdiction if a student is given poor guidance based on the fact that they are Jewish,” said Marcus.

Campus discussions of Israel-Palestine have long been polluted with overt personal biases and intra-group hostility.  Whether this precedent serves to help fix these problems or simply exacerbates them remains to be seen. This is especially important as several Jewish organizations have been arguing for a revision of college civil rights laws that would include protections for Jews.

Blog for New Voices this semester! [Awesomeness]

January 17th, 2012 by Harpo Jaeger

We’re looking for students to contribute regularly to our blog this semester and beyond!  If you’re interested, please email me, New Voices Web Editor Harpo Jaeger, at harpo@newvoices.org, with the following material:

  • Your name
  • Your school
  • Your graduation year
  • A sample of your previous writing
  • An example of the type of content you’d like to write for New Voices (approximately 500 words)

New Voices bloggers contribute on a biweekly schedule, and most cover a specific area.  We’re particularly interested in arts & culture, but will gladly review submissions in other areas as well.

Santorum in a Jewish frat? Emphasis on the ‘-ish’

January 9th, 2012 by Zach C. Cohen

via TalkMediaNews on flickr (CC BY-NC-SA 2.0)

Yep. You heard correctly. Former Pennsylvania Senator and current presidential candidate Rick Santorum was a brother in Tau Epsilon Phi, a historically Jewish fraternity.

Before Santorum graduated in 1980, he joined the Epsilon Phi chapter of TEP at Pennsylvania State. The chapter is now dormant.

Don’t worry, the super-Catholic candidate for the White House didn’t compromise his beliefs. TEP was  originally founded at Columbia University by 10 Jewish men. But in the 1950s, the Tau Boys, along with many other fraternitites, opened their doors to non-Jewish brothers. TEP welcomed Catholics in particular, like Santorum.

It’s the closest thing we’ve had to having a non-goyim in the White House since Lieberman in 2000.

But not really.

Not even close.